If you like your present local government, you can keep it. Just ignore the current election cycle, or vote for incumbents, and in most races, whoever is in office will stay in office. Be aware, however, that a “Whatever” or “Whoever” attitude among voters usually results in complacent office holders who have little motivation to do a better job (or even a good one). Not that incumbents can’t be outstanding in their performance. We all know exemplary office holders we don’t want to lose. The key to effective government is in our own hands – we have to care enough to understand each office; what it takes to discharge its duties with merit; hold incumbents accountable for high performance; and vet challengers for their abilities, character, and vision.
Early voting continues through Saturday July 30 at these locations for the August 4, 2016 local election. At stake are the Republican and Democrat primary nominees for the 8th and 9th Congressional District seats and several State House and Senate races. Local races include five Shelby County Schools district commissioners, two judgeships, and the General Sessions Court clerkship. With the exception of the hotly contested 8th Congressional District race, which is receiving wide media attention, few of the races are the kind that compel voters to brief themselves on leading issues and make sure they get to the polls. Many are uncontested – including four of five seats on the school board – and in others, the incumbents are disproportionately favored over their challengers.
Elections like this are opportunities for voters to focus on a few obscure, unexciting or less familiar elected offices, become better informed, and use the power of their votes to improve government performance. So, instead of producing a full voters guide, Back in River City decided to focus on just one race – an elective office under-analyzed by local news media and less understood by the electorate.
The General Sessions Court Clerk is an office with massive responsibilities, one that touches hundreds of thousands of Shelby County residents each year – far more than any other judicial post. Many voters are uncertain how to vote in this race. They do not have a clear idea of what the office does, how the incumbent is performing, or what a candidate should bring to the table. Back in River City decided to investigate the actual performance of the office to give a well-informed recommendation.
We didn’t know we were taking a bite from an elephant.
That’s why this post is coming out two weeks late, and less complete than we would like. Consider this Part One of an evolving story on how Memphis government works and how our votes can make it work better.
General Sessions Court Clerk
If you already know what the General Sessions Court Clerk does, you might be a reality tv fan.
Tennessee’s General Sessions Courts were created in 1960 to replace the former justice of the peace system. Also known as small claims courts or the courts of first resort (think Judge Judy or Memphis’ own Judge Joe Brown – umm, on second thought, better stick with Judge Judy), General Sessions courts try minor civil and criminal cases and preliminary matters in major criminal cases. General Sessions Courts do not impanel juries. They have the power to set bonds and to issue both arrest and search warrants. Each Tennessee County has at least one General Sessions Court.
Shelby County’s General Sessions Courts comprise 15 divisions and judges. Divisions 1-6 hear a host of civil matters including traffic violations (Tennessee Highway Patrol and Sheriff’s Department citations), landlord/tenant conflicts, domestic relations matters, evictions, denials of handgun permits, emergency medical commitments, and actions to recover personal property (including hot checks). Dollar amounts on cases other than recovery of personal property are limited to $25,000 or less.
Criminal Divisions 7-15 handle misdemeanor charges (where the defendant has waived the right to a grand jury investigation or trial by jury) and preliminary hearings for felony cases. Division 7 serves as Veterans Court. Division 8 is Shelby County’s Drug Court. Division 10 is set aside for Domestic Violence cases. Division 14 is Environmental Court, which handles zoning, planning, and other cases related to a cleaner, safer Shelby County.
The Office of the General Sessions Court Clerk (OGSCC) keeps records, assigns cases, and handles funds for all 15 courts. The salary for our General Sessions Court Clerk was $117,453 in FY2015. In recent history, at least, the post has been considered a political plum with multiple perquisites – status; influence; and a flock of good-paying, secure jobs to be awarded in a city where government positions are a direct path to the middle class for many born into poverty.
The office of Shelby County General Sessions Court Clerk has been sought and held by colorful, powerful, and influential people. Former State Senator John Ford served for one term (1992-1996). Eleven years later, back in the State Senate, he was convicted of multiple counts of bribery in the FBI’s Tennessee Waltz sting and imprisoned for 66 months. Current General Sessions Criminal Court Judge Chris Turner, a former member of the Tennessee House of Representatives, served three terms as GSC Clerk (1996-2008) before losing his fourth term bid to Otis Jackson. He was elected a GS Criminal Judge in 2010. Mr. Jackson, an early 1980’s basketball star at then Memphis State, was suspended in 2011 for 60 days with pay after being indicted by a grand jury for official misconduct. Mr. Jackson was acquitted after agreeing to a one-year pretrial diversion. The grand jury found that Clerk Jackson “engaged in the coercion for political purposes of employees or used his position for political purposes.”
Current officeholder Ed Stanton, Jr. (father of U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton, III) had over 25 years experience in the OGSCC (not as Clerk) prior to his 2011 appointment. He headed the civil division of the OGSCC during John Ford’s term. He ran for a full four-year term in 2012, winning the Democratic primary narrowly against former County Commissioner Sidney Chism.
While political connections and opportunities have long been integral components of the job in Shelby County, the checkered history of some officeholders should give voters pause to consider the kind of GSC Clerk candidate who will do the best job. Effective administration of such manifold responsibilities requires specific levels of education, training, experience, and managerial skills.
So, how do we know whether to vote for the incumbent, or if one of the challengers would be more effective in office?
Q. What objective measures are used to measure the performance of an incumbent GSC Clerk?
A. Accountability in the OGSCC is generally limited to re-electibility. There is not much formal oversight beyond external audits. (Back in River City is attempting to learn how often external audits are conducted and to obtain copies of recent audits.)
The 15 division judges do have the ability to remove a GSC Clerk.Twelve of 15 General Sessions judges voted to suspend Clerk Otis Jackson for 60 days with pay in 2011 following the grand jury charges.
Q. How should a GSC Clerk’s performance be evaluated?
A. Back in River City believes that every elected office holder should be held to specific standards of efficiency, accuracy, and resource management. The GSC Clerk should uphold high standards of transparency and accessibility to the public, providing taxpayers and other citizens useful information about the Courts and the OGSCC, including its accomplishments, performance measurement, and goals. The staff should provide courteous and efficient service to those who use the courts (attorneys, litigants and defendants) and to those who pay for them (that would be us taxpayers). The GSC Clerk should also demonstrate high performance in the selection, training, development and efficient use of employees; and prudent application of scarce resources.
Q. How well is our current GSC Clerk performing?
A. This is where Back in River City’s journey became circuitous, frustrating, and slow as mud in the Mighty Mississippi. It is disturbingly difficult to find useful information about the current or past operations of the OGSCC. Unlike that of Nashville Metro, Shelby County’s OGSCC does not publish an annual report providing measures of accountability to the public. Our official OGSCC website is not only short on basic metrics, but contains confusing, apparently erroneous, information.
Back in River City attempted to contact Clerk Stanton for assistance. The email link on OGSCC’s official website, however, does not function, and the Clerk’s email is not public. Phone numbers are provided on the website for the civil and criminal divisions, but not for general questions of the Clerk’s office.
We ultimately sent our questions to Harvey Kennedy, Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) for Shelby County, and requested he forward them to Clerk Stanton. Mr. Kennedy did so promptly. After one week (July 26), we received courteous responses from the OGSCC ‘s CAO. Our follow-up questions received a prompt but disappointing response that answers would be provided by August 3rd, the day before Election Day — too late to be of much help to Back in River City followers.
During his 2012 campaign, Clerk Stanton promised to restore “the public’s trust” in the OGSCC; to “serve the citizens of Shelby County by operating the Clerk’s office in a transparent, effective and fiscally sound manner. . . [including] implementing safeguards and protocols to ensure that all funds maintained by the office, including its multi-million dollar budget, are accounted for and always utilized in the best interest of the taxpayers . . .[and to] Provide outstanding customer service . . . .”
He also promised to “enhance and modernize the office’s electronic technology capabilities by implementing e-filing and wireless capabilities, to provide a more efficient and user-friendly manner to serve the citizens.”
With an expense budget in the $8 million range, revenues between $9 – $10 million, and hundreds of thousands of court-related tasks completed each year, accuracy is essential to the job of General Sessions Court Clerk. Time constraints did not permit Back in River City to interview attorneys and others who interact regularly with the OGSCC. We had to rely on published facts; primarily, approved Shelby County budget documents, Consolidated Annual Financial Reports (CAFRs), and archived news reports.These sources gave an incomplete picture and raised numerous questions about missing reports, conflicting statements, and statistical discrepancies.
Back in River City obtained a copy of a 2010 Shelby County audit of the OGSCC. The audit revealed a history of systematic accounting problems and management deficiencies dating back to John Ford’s tenure as General Sessions Court Clerk (1992-1996) and extending through the terms of Chris Turner (1996-2008) and Otis Jackson (2008-2011). It was unclear whether or not problems were found in areas previously managed by Ed Stanton. Clerk Stanton did have access to the audit when he began his pro tempore appointment to GSC Clerk in 2011, and should have addressed the issues immediately. Back in River City is working to document what corrective measures Clerk Stanton has since taken to ensure accuracy and efficiency in the OGSCC and to “restore the public’s trust” per his 2012 campaign promise.
While campaigning for his first elected term in 2012, Clerk Stanton cited his prior experience as a competitive strength over his challengers. He also announced, just weeks before the general election, that the OGSCC would be refunding an estimated $300,000 in overpaid GS court fees and fines to some 2,400 individuals. Local media touted the news, and Clerk Stanton won the election handily. Here’s an excerpt from a campaign interview:
Based on an internal audit I commissioned, my finance team recently identified nearly $300,000 in overpayments that were made unknowingly by citizens to the Clerk’s office over the past 12 years. Instead of these funds being remitted to the State of Tennessee, I swiftly instituted a process for the 2,400 individuals who overpaid the Clerk’s Office to reclaim these funds
Official documents obtained by Back in River City recorded the actual amount of overpayments as $227,745.63. (We have requested documentation of the number of overcharged citizens.) The overpayments were discovered in the 2010 audit conducted before Clerk Stanton held the office; not, as he claimed, one that he authorized. The “swift process” he refers to was not so swift, and not as direct-to-citizen as implied.
The Tennessee Treasury Department, Department of Unclaimed Property, acknowledged acceptance of a check on May 28, 2013 for a $227,745.63 check signed by Clerk Stanton on May 13, 2013 – nearly a year after he announced the process was in place. The overpayments had not been reimbursed previously to citizens because the OGSCC did not have current or accurate addresses for the parties owed. Unclaimed funds such as these are required to be escheated to the State’s Unclaimed Property division. Once a year, that agency publishes names of all persons owed escheated funds relinquished from banks, businesses or government agencies in newspapers across the State. Most citizens due refunds from the OGSCC would be unaware they had overpaid. To obtain the money due them, they would have to file a claim after seeing the published notification of Unclaimed Funds in their name.
The home page for the General Sessions Courts civil divisions reports handling over 65,000 new cases each year. The home page for the criminal divisions states that over 100,000 criminal cases are handled each year, for a combined civil-criminal case total of 165,000.
Elsewhere on the website, however (see “Statistics”), graphs appear showing 95,012 as the “Yearly Total” of 2015 “Events” (a term used elsewhere on the site as an alias for cases) and an average of 100,000 “Events” annually for the period 2010-2015. These graphs are of little to no value to taxpayers, because the have no legend or links to define “Events.” The graph totals do not correspond with audited data appearing on the CAFR for for 2015. The CAFR reports 62,251 civil cases filed in General Sessions courts in 2015, and 193,293 criminal cases.
Shelby County budgeting procedures require departments to provide “Service Level Measurements” or task/paperwork volumes, which allow comparison from year to year. The OGSCC’s approved budget estimated the following services to be rendered in FY2016:
- 78,854 Civil Lawsuits – Leading Actions
- 55,454 Complete Filings
- 5,593 Emergency Mental Commitment Cases
- 44,015 Non-Leading Civil Actions
- 388,247 Non-Leading Processes
- 39,991 Post-Judgment Procedures (i.e., Garnishments)
No combination of these numbers adds up to the “Cases” or “Events” quoted on the OGSCC web site. If staff cannot accurately report its volume of work to the public on its own website, it raises questions about accuracy elsewhere in the department where money is on the line.
- 133,963 Arraignments
- 9,192 Drivers License Recovery Program
- 49,208 Escrow Skip Sessions
- 46,306 Misdemeanor Citations
- 54,436 Traffic Tickets
Again, it is impossible to reconcile these numbers with what appears on the criminal division web page. Back in River City has requested clarification.
In some cases, data provided to Back in River City by the CAO of OGSCC did not match what was reported in CAFRs or published in Shelby County Approved Budget documents. We are continuing to work with the CAO to determine the reason for the discrepancies and ascertain the correct statistics. As an example, the OGSCC has a reported FTE (full-time equivalent employees) complement of 149 employees in its existing (FY 2017) approved budget. Back in River City was told that there are currently 160 employees. We have asked for clarification.
Transparency: Incomplete but Improving.
Management Skill and Use of Resources: ??
Back in River City attempted to calculate the net cost to taxpayers of the OGSCC, beginning with a base year of FY 2008, the last full budget year under former Clerk Chris Turner. We also analyzed OGSCC Revenues from General Funds (not Grant Funds) and Personnel Expense based on CAFR data. We attempted to carry the analysis through FY 2015, the last year for which audited results are available, in order to evaluate performance for various GSC Clerks during the eight-year period.
In FY 2012, during Otis Jackson’s last year, Shelby County’s Finance Department stopped publishing separate budgets for Court Clerks in the Criminal, Chancery, Probate, and General Sessions Courts. The separate Judges accounts and Clerk’s Office accounts were rolled up into one account on the CAFR and Approved Budget documents. This accounting change (which, for some reason, did not apply to Juvenile Court for three years) prevented performance analysis of the Court Clerks by the Shelby County Mayor, County Commissioners, news media, or taxpayers unless they requested and obtained internal budget documents from the Clerks’ offices. Separate Clerks’ office budgets were restored to the Shelby County Approved Budget in FY 2017.
Back in River City has requested the missing documents from OGSCC to complete our analysis, and will publish our findings later. Regrettably for voters, this will occur after the August 4, 2016 election. What we do know, however, is that OGSCC revenues from various fees, fines, and court costs are higher than expenses of running the office. In other words, the OGSCC generates a surplus. When the expenses and revenues of the various GS Court Judges are included, however, total expenses exceed total revenues.
We know from our preliminary analysis that in the fiscal year (FY) ending June 30, 2008, the OGSCC earned a surplus of over $2.5 million dollars. Currently, the amount appears to be less than half of that number. Personnel expenses have risen dramatically, beginning in Otis Jackson’s term, and continue to rise each year. Based on our preliminary numbers, the average cost of salary, fringe benefits and other compensation on a per-employee basis has risen from $33,346 in FY 2008 to nearly $53,000 in FY 2017. These numbers were based on published FTE quotas and may change when we receive more information from the OGSCC.
Education and Training: D
Clerk Stanton’s extensive prior experience in the OGSCC office is not sufficient in our eyes to recommend him for re-election. He has only been in the GSC Clerk position since 2011. Back in River City has been unable to verify that he has the management skills and accounting expertise to make the deep structural changes called for in the 2010 audit. He lists attendance at the University of Memphis on his Linked-In page (in Criminal Justice), but apparently did not earn a degree.
An ethics complaint was filed in 2014 against Clerk Stanton by OGSCC CAO William Stovall, who alleged that he was fired after refusing to make a donation to Clerk Stanton’s campaign fund in 2013. Mr. Stovall was also OGSCC CAO under former GS Clerk Otis Jackson, who was indicted in 2011 on four counts of pressuring employees for campaign donations and subsequently left the office. Mr. Stovall said in the complaint, according to FOX 13 News, that other OGSCC employees had been similarly pressured. Fox 13 also quoted him as stating the solicitations were made by an OGSCC colleague, not by Clerk Stanton directly. Back in River City has been unable to learn whether the complaint led to any investigation by the County’s ethics committee. We did find what appeared to be a redacted version of the complaint on the internet.
Earlier this year, a discrimination lawsuit was filed by an OGSCC employee against Shelby County. In the suit, Clerk Stanton was accused of inappropriately touching the employee. The suit was settled out of court in April.
Back in River City’s research on all three candidates in the race included examination of their Campaign Financial Disclosure Statements. For the period July 1, 2015 through January 15, 2016, Clerk Stanton reported only two expenditures, including a $250 contribution to Hillary for America. While such contributions are not illegal, Back in River City considers it unethical for a candidate to to divert campaign funds contributed to him to a candidate for another office. A better choice would have been for Clerk Stanton to use his personal funds to make a contribution to the presidential candidate of his choice.
Fifty-four percent of respondents in a Memphis & Shelby County Bar Association member said that Clerk Stanton is “best qualified” of the three candidates in the race. We disagree. Overall, Back in River City’s analysis to date leads us to believe that Memphis needs more skills and less politics in the elected office of General Sessions Court Clerk.
Clerk Stanton, a party-loyal Democrat, is opposed in the current election by Republican Richard Morton and William Chism, Jr., who is running as an independent.
William Chism, Jr.
William Chism, Jr. is a native Memphian and Whitehaven High School graduate who grew up in a family business, Chism Trail Supermarket. He attended Shelby State Community College, but does not claim he earned a degree. Since 2007 he has been principal of Chism Process Service. He ran unsuccessfully for Probate Court Clerk in 2014 and for City Court Clerk in 2015. Mr. Chism does not have a campaign website. His campaign Facebook page contains almost no background information on him.
Commercial Appeal (CA) reporters found in their 2015 investigation of City Court Clerk candidates that Mr. Chism filed five bankruptcies during the period 1995-2004. At that time, he owed $13,318 to First Tennessee Bank from a judgment filed in 2013. Mr. Chism appealed a 2013 First Tennessee breach of contract suit by a pauper’s oath, according to an unofficial document from Shelby County files available on the internet.
While 10 of 844 attorneys responding to the Memphis Bar Association’s Candidate Qualifications Poll voted Mr. Chism as more qualified than Clerk Stanton or Richard Morton, Back in River City respectfully finds Mr. Chism unqualified to serve as Shelby County General Sessions Court Clerk.
Richard Morton is presently Head of Accounting for the Shelby County Probate Court. The Probate Court handles conservatorships, corrections to birth certificates, guardianships, name changes, wills and estates, and judicial hospitalization under our mental health laws. Its expense budget in FY 2015 was $1,140,887.
Mr. Morton earned a degree from the University of Memphis. His campaign website lays out a specific platform to improve the performance of the court, including:
Collections: Go back to a more proactive collections policy that makes the criminals pay their court cost, instead of their tax paying neighbors who chose to do their part and stay out of trouble.
Technology: Put a new focus on technological improvement. Pushing advancements and updates to be implemented sooner will not only save in operational costs, but will also save in the capital improvement budget.
Streamlining management: Management in General Sessions is too big, the office can easily get by with fewer high paid managers if they are encouraged to get out of their offices and work with the people who work for them. This will bring about a higher quality of work for the public as well.
Mr. Morton is an active Republican and board member for the Tennessee Board of Communication Disorders and Sciences. He received 22% of the votes in the Memphis Bar Association poll for Most Qualified Candidate for GSC Clerk. Back in River City found no hint of impropriety or lack of performance associated with Mr. Morton. In our opinion, he is by far the most impressive of the three candidates for General Sessions Court Clerk.
How do we raise our standards for Metropolitan Memphis’ elected leaders? How do we realize greater transparency and accountability in government? The answer is:
We raise up and elect better qualified candidates.
In this race, Back in River City believes Richard Morton to be that candidate.
Back in River City will continue to provide updates as we receive additional insights and information about the OGSCC and its performance. These updates will continue past the election. Why? Because what we have learned – and will continue to learn – is important to all Shelby County voters. Individually, court clerk offices (Circuit, Probate, Criminal, Chancery, Juvenile, General Sessions) are considered too small by traditional news media for the level of performance analysis required for voters to make a truly informed, smart decision. Bar polls and recommendations from political parties and special interest groups can be shaped by factors that have nothing to do with which candidate would do the best job. As a result, voters seldom know if they made a smart choice. To make a better Memphis, we need more informed voters making smart choices.
Correction: Thanks to Ken Welch for catching our boo-boo identifying Sidney Chism as a current Shelby County Commissioner in the first issuance of this post (now corrected). Although the shelbycountytn.gov website still shows him as County Commissioner, he is now employed in the Shelby County Sheriff’s Department. George Chism is the current County Commissioner. (Now, will someone please correct the Shelby County government website?)
Hope. It’s something every Memphian wants to feel about our beloved but beleaguered city. Memphis is flush with people and programs, non-profits and commercial enterprises with a desire to solve problems and advance the well-being of all Memphians. How often, though, do you meet someone who not only fills you with hope that their efforts might make a real difference, but certainty that their efforts will reap success?
Kristoffer and Alisha Adams are people who inspire hope and confidence. They are a millennial power couple with a growing track record for community outreach that prepares rising generations to prosper, lead, and engage in responsible citizenship. Their work ethic and successful partnership as a couple are an inspiration. Kris (a Memphis native) and Alisha (from Lexington, Tennessee) met in a Jackson, Tennessee bookstore. They both matriculated at the University of Memphis in 2009; working and volunteering their way through a persistent course of study in political science enriched with real-world community outreach. They married in 2010, and on June 14, 2016 welcomed their firstborn Irene into the world, one month after Alisha was awarded her long-awaited bachelor’s degree.
While continuing to pursue his degree, Kris travels nationally as a sought-after political consultant and event organizer. He serves as National Outreach Coordinator for City GOP; is founder and CEO of two active not for profit organizations, My Just+Us and ValComm (Valued Communities); and sits on several boards, including Lifeline for Success and the Republican Liberty Caucus of Tennessee. At U of M, he has distinguished himself as a former College Republican of the Year; President of the College Republicans (2013-2014) and as Associate Justice of Student Government Court (2012-2014). Kris was Head Researcher and manager of the University’s Offender Re-Entry program through its Criminology Department between 2012-2104, while serving as the Shelby County Coordinator for S.H.A.P.E., a model diversionary program for minor juvenile offenders in the Shelby County Schools system.
The common denominator in Kris’s and Alisha’s work is a focus on rebuilding strong communities and lifting people out of poverty. Their philosophy is founded on conservative principles: personal responsibility, accountability for gifts given, and free-market principles.
drives, block parties, prayer breakfasts and outreach events for youth and adults. The couple have developed relationships of mutual respect and regard with a wealth of organizations, including influential local churches Kingdom Fellowship Baptist Church and Eureka True Vine Baptist Church, the local pastor alliance Mid-South Baptist Association, and Latinos for Tennessee . At the U of M, Kris finds insight and sometimes unexpected common ground in “side conversations” and ad hoc alliances with issue-based student groups such as College Democrats, Log Cabin Republicans, and LGBTQA rights advocates. Kris says,
“the messy stuff you always read about (between Republicans and liberal-issue groups) is not reflective of the actual” relationships that are forged on campus. “There is smart, real leadership to be found everywhere.”
Last summer, while helping students develop financial literacy, Kris and Alisha identified an equally pressing need: civic and political literacy. They found widespread “general ignorance” about public policy and the workings of state, local and federal governments among students (despite recently added Tennessee high school graduation requirements that include some government and civics classes). Similar educational shortfalls became apparent to Kris and Alisha among adults who attended voter registration drives. According to Kris, many vote without any basic understanding of how American government works, or even how it is structured. For example, they may know nothing about concepts such as checks and balances or the separation of powers in government.
The less voters know, the less able they are to vote in their own best interests.
The Adamses determined that this summer, they would change their focus from teaching students financial literacy to teaching them how to be effective citizens. Beginning in July, a selectively chosen group of 10-15 local high schoolers – “the best and the brightest” – will give up two days a week for at least five weeks to go through a “crash course in civics, government, public policy and law.” Classes will be held from 10:00 a.m to 4:00 p.m. on the LeMoyne-Owen campus, with lunches and supplies provided. Students will learn about governmental organization at federal, state, and local levels; about how bureaucracies work; about politicians and elected officialdom; the role of not for profits in the public good; and the individual’s role in public policy. They will be assigned homework, hear guest speakers including Shelby Co. Trustee David Lenoir, and go on field trips. The diverse class will engage in lively group discussions and experience writing their own legislation. Kris and Alisha hope to present each participant with a Chromebook as an incentive and reward for making the classes a summer priority.
The preliminary budget for the entire summer program is $16,000, which will include meals, supplies, t-shirts, Chromebooks and carrying cases, speaker honoraria, and modest compensation for staff. Kris and Alisha are actively raising funds for the program. If less than $16,000 is raised, cost-based items will be reduced as necessary, but the full curriculum will be taught.
It will take more than good intentions and money to solve Memphis’ problems. It will take more than vision to change our city’s future for the better. Memphis isn’t suffering because we need more volunteers, federal grants, 501 (c)3 enterprises, or taxes. We’re suffering because we are spending an abundance of our human and financial resources on efforts that are ineffective, duplicative, infeasible, or simply wrong-headed. It’s time to create and support efforts that will change hearts, minds, and the culture that shapes our children.
We at Back in River City are proud to be supporters of the 2016 Youth Policy Workshop sponsored by Valued Communities, and urge our followers to join us in supporting this worthwhile investment in Memphis area youth. Make your check payable to Valued Communities, 254 Greenway Rd., Memphis, TN 38117.
And, because we know you want to see the beautiful new mom and baby Irene:
Early voting began today and runs through November 14 for the Memphis City Council runoff elections. Election Day is November 19. Five positions in the October 8, 2015 election will be decided:
District 2: Frank Colvett vs. Rachel Knox
District 3: Patrice Jordan Robinson vs. Keith O. Williams
District 4: Doris DeBerry Bradshaw vs. Jamita E. Swearengen
District 5: Worth Morgan vs. Dan Springer
District 7: Anthony Anderson vs. Berlin Boyd (I)
Six incumbent Council members won another term, pulling a majority of votes in their districts:
- District 1: Bill Morrison (with 78.4% of the vote)
- District 6: Edmund Ford, Jr. (74%)
- Super District 8, Position 1: Joe Brown (71.9%)
- Super District 8, Position 2: Janis Fullilove (78.2%)
- Super District 9, Position 1: Kemp Conrad (72.4%)
- Super District 9, Position 3: Reid Hedgepeth (64.7%)
Former Memphis City Schools Board member and President Martavius D. Jones won the Super District 8, Position 3 seat on the Council capturing 45% of the vote, and newcomer Phillip C. Spinosa won the Super District 9, Position 2 race with 49.4% of the vote.
Back in River City’s 2015 Vote Smart Guide to Memphis Elections published in September provides information and recommendations on the candidates now facing runoffs. Here are our additional thoughts as you prepare to head back to the polls.
First, do make the effort to vote in the runoffs. Voting participation is consistently dreadful in local runoff elections. The selection of who represents your voice in the management of Memphis matters. If you visit the polls during early voting, it will be a quick in-and-out.
Second. Seven Council incumbents will be involved in leading Memphis for the next four years, including Mayor-Elect Jim Strickland, who is exiting as District 5’s representative. The newcomers will have significant influence in determining the group dynamics and culture of our city’s principal governing body. Let’s hold them accountable for honesty, integrity, preparation, cooperation, civility, thoughtful planning, listening to (and representing the wishes of) their constituents, and effective policy-making. And definitely no pole dancing.
Third. Too many of our elected Council members are current or former school board members or employees of Memphis City Schools/Shelby County Schools. The decisions of City Council members should be completely independent of their private and professional interests. Memphis can find better Council representation than those associated with a governmental agency (past or present) known for inefficiencies, bad decisions, nepotism, incompetent workers, and failure.
Refer to Back in River City’s Vote Smart general election guide for additional information on the candidates.
In District 2, Frank Colvett won 49.7% of the general election vote against Rachel Knox’s 22.6%.
Rachel Knox, a 2011 Bachelor of Fine Arts graduate of the University of Memphis, is to be congratulated for winning a runoff spot in a tough race of four. As the Orpheum’s Education Coordinator, she organizes workshops for teachers and manages an internal grant program providing students exposure to the arts. She was inspired to enter local politics just over a year ago after making an impassioned speech before the City Council on behalf of fire, police and other city workers facing pension and benefit cuts as a result of the City’s financial crisis.
Frank Colvett is co-owner of a family landscape and irrigation business. He is an employer in a city whose populace is massively underemployed. He knows first-hand the problems confronting local businesses seeking to survive in a competitive market while government officials favor set-asides for “disadvantaged minorities.” We believe Mr. Colvett would bring a much-needed skill set to the Council. Back in River City recommends Frank Colvett in the District 2 race.
Patrice Jordan Robinson won 48.5% of the general election vote to Keith O. Williams’ 20.8%. Ms Robinson served on the Memphis City Schools Board for 13 years and also served as its President. She has been employed by MCS and MLG&W. Mr. Williams is a retired Shelby County Schools teacher and immediate past president of the local teachers union. Back in River City makes no recommendation in this race.
The runoff is between retired Bank of America employee Doris DeBerry-Bradshaw (33.1% of the vote) and Jamita E. Swearengen (24.5%). Ms Swearengen is employed by Shelby County Schools. The Commercial Appeal reported in July that Ms Swearengen owed back taxes on multiple properties in Memphis. Back in River City makes no recommendation in this race.
Good news for residents of District 5! Back in River City’s Eddie Settles recently interviewed both candidates, and we feel that either would be an excellent addition to the Memphis City Council. They shared their thoughts and concerns about major issues such as Memphis policing, finances, and outmigration; and the role of metrics in measuring performance of city government functions. They both answered these questions:
- What do you understand to be the job description of a Memphis City Council member?
- How will your constituents hold you accountable?
Dan Springer believes he is supposed to be a team player, finding a way to help build consensus instead of contributing to discord. Worth Morgan defines his desired Council office as representing the interests of his constituents while also doing his best to seek the common good for all Memphians. Both are committed to holding frequent townhall meetings in District 5 to provide information about pending Council decisions and hear constituents’ concerns.
We at Back in River City are excited to see two such intelligent and capable young men
interested in serving Memphis. Both are worthy of your support. We have a slim preference for Dan Springer only because he has more years of hands-on government service experience from previous stints working with Senator Bob Corker and Shelby County Mayor Mark Luttrell. We expect good things in the political futures of both candidates.
The District 7 runoff pits Anthony Anderson (24.1% in the general election) against incumbent Berlin Boyd (26.5%). Back in River City endorsed Mr. Anderson in the general election and we continue to favor him over Mr. Boyd. Mr. Anderson is CEO of Frayser charter school The Memphis Business Academy. He has been actively involved in Frayser civic affairs since 1995. Mr. Boyd was appointed to his current Council seat in 2014, filling the vacancy left by Tennessee Senator Lee Harris. Earlier, he served for 11 months as the replacement for District 7 Council member Barbara Swearengen Ware, who was indicted on a charge of official misconduct. In our opinion, Mr. Boyd’s vocational interests – principal of government relations firm Boyd and Associates and commercial real estate agent – are in conflict with exercising independent judgment in a City Council role.
Source of voting statistics: ballotpedia.org
He’s one of the most honored and respected African Americans in the world. His life story is the quintessential American dream: the impoverished black son of an illiterate single mother, reared on the gritty streets of Detroit, nicknamed “Dummy” by his middle school classmates for his poor school performance, becomes an internationally acclaimed pediatric neurosurgeon and is awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom. He and his wife have raised and donated millions of dollars since 2004 to award over 2000 college scholarships and create 131 reading rooms in public schools to provide at risk-youth the opportunity to realize their own dreams. His books and biographical movie have been studied in classrooms across American and have inspired untold numbers of Americans of all races.
Now Dr. Ben Carson is a top presidential candidate, with new polls daily showing him edging out the infamous Donald Trump and leaving the rest of the Republican candidates trailing in his dust.
But don’t expect the Tri-State Defender or Commercial Appeal to tell you how to hear him in person tomorrow in West Memphis. They fear his viral appeal because he states his mind, faith, and traditional American values openly, denouncing Democrat leaders who manipulate black voters and the political correctness that silences voices daring to speak the truth. People across the country and around the world are eager to learn more about Dr. Ben Carson and to hear his common sense plans for healing and reviving our country. Back in River City published a 2013 post about his unpublicized, deliberately ignored speech at the University of Memphis. That post has attracted well over 5,000 readers – our most popular ever – and continues to draw new readers to Back in River City every day.
Eddie and I will be at West Memphis High School tomorrow to hear Dr. Carson. The political rally begins at 6:00 p.m., with doors opening at 4:00. Click here to register. We will report on the rally next week.
Correction: Ooops! We goofed up. (Thank goodness no one pays us for this gig.) Kyle Veazey noted Dr. Carson’s West Memphis appearance in his Commercial Appeal column on Tuesday, October 27. We are CA subscribers and readers, but goblins must have been afoot in our house that day because Eddie and I totally missed it. We apologize for the error and dig at the CA. Thanks to the vigilant Back in River City reader who informed us of this error. Keep us honest, folks!
How many of your close friendships have been truly life-changing, have re-shaped the way you think and act, have made you wiser and your life more fulfilling?
That is way more than anyone should expect from a friendship, but is exactly the gift that two Memphis women have given me. They are both African American, while I am Caucasian – a fact unremarkable by itself, but in racially-torn Memphis is worth mentioning. A close cross-racial friendship in Memphis is a stitch in an open wound, a strike against divisive politics and ingrained preconceptions. It is also an adventure of discovering how different and yet how alike two people can be, sharing laughter and experiences and points of view, finding a safe place where trust and love can flourish despite all odds.
In 2014, Back in River City posted about a budding new group called Soul Sisters, formed to facilitate intentional one-on-one relationships between Memphis women of different races and ethnicities. I went to the first Soul Sisters event (a tea at Harding Academy) to learn about the group and write about them. I left with a match-up to an amazing woman who has become a dear friend.
Soul Sisters was inspired by the accidental meeting of the Rev. Dr. Earnestine Hunt and Lorie Affatato at a Collierville garage sale 15 years ago. They became fast friends. After Lorie moved to Florida, Earnestine hoped to find someone who would help her launch an organization that would facilitate and encourage cross-racial friendships. She found that someone in Shelby County Commissioner Heidi Shafer. For more on this story, see Back in River City’s original post here.
A second Soul Sisters match-up will be held at the Crescent Club, 4:00-7:00 p.m. on Saturday November 14, 2016. Registrants will enjoy a 3-course dinner, meet dynamic women interested in healing Memphis race relations, hear about successful Soul Sister friendships, and be matched to a Soul Sister for their own “intentional friendship.” There are no rules to follow, but matched Soul Sisters are asked to make a commitment to get together at least once a month for a year to let a relationship take root.
Contact Tammy Gaitor Miller at (901) 830-6088 for more information and to register for the event. But hurry! Registration and payment ($37 covers dinner, tax and gratuity) are due by Sunday, November 1st. You may also contact Tammy via the Soul Sisters Facebook page or by email at email@example.com.
The complete and final version of Back in River City’s 2015 Vote Smart Guide to Memphis Elections is ready for you to view. When you send your friends to Back in River City, tell them to click on the tab marked 2015 Voter Guide. For those of you reading this, just click here. (If I believe you are not reading this, I must be having a senior moment and need to get a grip.)
Hundreds of you have already viewed the mayoral portion of the Vote Smart guide posted Friday. We have added the City Council races (all 60 candidates) and the race for City Court Clerk.
You don’t have to agree with our recommendations, but we hope you will take the time to review the candidates, issues, and the questions that will help you to make your own best choices. Back in River City‘s Vote Smart Guides are the most comprehensive, candid, and insightful voter guides available in the Memphis metropolitan area. You have asked us to produce these guides and we are happy to oblige.
Let us know what you think and what you want to see next from Back in River City.
Thank you! We love our followers who want to join us in building a better Memphis.
“Just in time” is our motto here at Back in River City. Some people call this “waiting until the last minute.” But those people don’t have houses in the midst of a remodel, and a hubby who needs his shirts pressed so he can shine as Bow Tie Guy and lots of other stuff to do. All excuses aside, however, we just published the first section of our 2015 Vote Smart Guide to Memphis Elections as a new page on Back in River City. Click here to learn everything you need to know about the mayoral candidates. Tomorrow we’ll post our thoughts and recommendations about the City Council and City Court Clerk candidates. Tell your friends to come to http://www.backinrivercity.com and click on the tab marked 2015 Voters Guide.
Early voting begins tomorrow, Friday, September 18 for you early birds. The Guide will tell you when and where to go and what to take with you.
Thank you for your gracious and enthusiastic support of Back in River City’s Vote Smart Guides. We prepare these guides because we love our city. If we all vote smarter, with more information about the candidates and who might be best for the job, together we will make a better Memphis.